Freshly Made Pizza in Siesta Key, FL

Serving Siesta Key, South Sarasota, and the Stickney Point community, Cafe Amalfi has become a go-to spot for those searching “best pizza near me.” Our kitchen is inspired by family recipes passed down through generations, bringing the heart of Italian tradition to every plate. From perfectly hand-tossed pizzas to hearty pastas made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, each dish is crafted with authenticity and care. Join us at 1880 Stickney Point Rd. in Sarasota and experience the flavor, warmth, and tradition of Italy right in your neighborhood.

Pizza That Brings People Together in Siesta Key


Our Menu: Authentic Italian Pizza and Pasta

Cafe Amalfi invites you to enjoy handcrafted pizzas and hearty pastas made with the freshest ingredients. Recognized as a local favorite for those searching “pizza near me” in Siesta Key and Sarasota, our menu blends authentic Italian tradition with unforgettable flavor. From Margherita and Pepperoni to our signature Cafe Amalfi Special, every pizza is baked to perfection. Add in classic pastas, fresh salads, and house-made desserts, and you have a true Italian dining experience just minutes from the beach.

Your Neighborhood Pizza Spot

When the craving for pizza hits, Cafe Amalfi is the go-to spot for Siesta Key, South Sarasota, and Stickney Point locals. Our menu features hand-tossed pizzas baked to perfection alongside hearty pastas that keep our guests coming back. Searching for “pizza near me”? You’ll find authentic Italian flavors right here.

Tradition Served Fresh

Inspired by recipes passed down through generations, every dish we serve is made with fresh ingredients and a passion for Italian cooking. From classic Margherita to our signature Cafe Amalfi Special, each slice is crafted with care. Pair your pizza with pastas, salads, or house-made desserts and enjoy a true taste of Italy by the beach.

Authentic Italian Dining Near Siesta Key

Cafe Amalfi is a local favorite just off Stickney Point, serving Gulf Gate Estates and Sarasota with the flavors of Italy. Our menu highlights hand-tossed pizzas, rich pastas, and savory entrées made from the freshest ingredients. Whether you’re enjoying a casual dinner or a family night out, every dish is crafted with warmth, tradition, and true Italian flavor.