Authentic Italian Pizza Near Gulf Gate Estates, FL

Discover Authentic Pizza Near Me

Cafe Amalfi brings authentic Italian flavors to South Sarasota and the Stickney Point area, making us a favorite choice for anyone searching for the best pizza near me. Inspired by family recipes passed down through generations, every dish reflects the passion and heritage of true Italian cuisine. From hand-tossed pizzas baked to perfection to hearty pastas prepared with the finest ingredients, each bite delivers warmth and authenticity. Visit us at 1880 Stickney Point Rd. in Sarasota, where every meal is an invitation to experience the genuine taste of Italy close to home.


Our Menu: Authentic Italian Pizza and Pasta

At Cafe Amalfi, we showcase the true flavors of Italy with handcrafted pizzas and hearty pastas at the heart of our menu. Celebrated as one of the best pizza spots near me in South Sarasota and the Stickney Point area, we prepare every dish with the freshest ingredients for flavor and satisfaction in every bite. From timeless favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni to our signature Cafe Amalfi Special, each pizza is baked to golden perfection. Complement your pie with traditional pastas, crisp salads, and indulgent desserts for a complete Italian dining experience right here in Sarasota.

Italian Takeout in South Sarasota

At Cafe Amalfi, we know that some of the best meals are enjoyed right at home. That’s why we make takeout easy and convenient for our South Sarasota and Stickney Point neighbors searching for pizza or pasta near me. From hand-tossed pizzas baked to perfection to freshly prepared pastas made with family recipes, your favorite Italian dishes are just a call or online order away. We’ll have everything hot, fresh, and ready for pickup in no time - so you can bring the taste of Italy home from Cafe Amalfi.

A Local Favorite Near You

Cafe Amalfi has become a beloved destination for locals near Stickney Point and throughout South Sarasota who crave genuine flavors and warm hospitality. From hand-tossed pizzas baked to perfection to hearty pastas and chef-inspired specialties, every dish celebrates tradition while offering unforgettable taste. It’s no wonder so many loyal guests consider Cafe Amalfi their go-to choice when searching for the best food near me in Sarasota.

Experience Flavor at Cafe Amalfi

Step into Cafe Amalfi and enjoy the warmth, flavor, and tradition of true Italian cooking just off Stickney Point near Gulf Gate Estates. From hand-tossed pizzas baked to perfection to classic pastas and savory entrées, every dish is crafted to be shared and remembered. Visit us at 1880 Stickney Point Rd. in Sarasota and see why so many locals searching for pizza and pasta near me choose Cafe Amalfi as their favorite neighborhood spot.